Ressources / Application

TPMS Packet Loss by Wheel Position: Real Field Data

· 5 min de lecture

Why one tyre position lost 37% of its packets

Most TPMS suppliers will tell you their system is reliable. Almost none will publish a packet-loss number.

We will. Here is a full measurement from a Zoomlion reach stacker - six sensors, 4,189 valid packets, logged at the CAN output of the receiver. The machine type matters: this is a reach stacker, a machine whose body is steel on every side of the signal path.

The measurement

PositionValid packetsLost packetsLoss eventsLoss rate
Front left, outer766851.03%
Front right, outer7591431.81%
Rear right7482062.60%
Front left, inner70762278.06%
Rear left44626614237.36%
Front right, inner7631051.29%
All six4,1893801888.32%

The pattern is the point

Look at which positions are fine and which are not.

The three outer positions sit between 1.0% and 1.8%. That is normal for a 433 MHz link on a working machine. The rear left position lost more than a third of its packets.

That is not a sensor failing. The outer positions use the same sensor, the same firmware and the same battery. They work.

What was different about the rear left position was where its packets had to travel.

The three things that were stacked against it

1. The receiver was in the wrong end of the cab.

On this machine the receiver was fitted at the front of the cab, on the driver's left. The rear left wheel is the furthest point on the machine from that receiver. The signal had to cross the whole chassis.

2. There was no repeater.

The machine had no spare power take-off at the time, so no repeater could be fitted. Every packet had to make the full trip on its own. That is the difference between a layout that is planned and one that is not - we go through the method on how a TPMS repeater works and on multi-axle repeater planning.

3. It was behind steel.

A reach stacker is not a truck. Between the wheel and the cab there is the spreader, the boom and the frame - all steel. 433 MHz does not pass through steel. It goes around it, and going around costs signal.

Why this is a physics problem, not a product problem

Here is the part most suppliers will not say out loud:

Any 433 MHz TPMS will lose packets behind a steel spreader. The band is licence-free and worldwide, it survives dirt and vibration, and it goes a long way in open air. What it does not do is pass through a steel plate.

The question is not "does your system lose packets". It does. Every 433 MHz system does.

The question is whether the supplier measured it, and whether they plan the repeaters for it.

What fixed it

Not a different sensor. A repeater at the rear of the machine.

That is what the customer is fitting next. They reached that conclusion themselves after seeing this data - which is how it should work. We are not selling repeaters. We are showing where the signal dies, and the customer decides where to put the fix.

What this means if you run a fleet

If you are specifying TPMS on port equipment, mining equipment or anything with a steel body, three things will decide whether your system works. The wider set of machines and layouts is on the port machinery TPMS page.

1. Where the receiver goes. Front of the cab is not automatically right. On a reach stacker it can be the worst place on the machine. The centre of the chassis, or the rear, often covers more evenly.

2. How many repeaters you need - and where. "One repeater" is not a plan. The number depends on the machine geometry, not on the tyre count.

3. Whether the supplier has numbers. Ask for a packet-loss log per wheel position, on a machine like yours. If they cannot produce one, they have not measured it on that class of machine.

Ask us for the log

We can send you the full test log from this machine - every packet, every lost sequence number, the analysis script.

```

Send us the machine type and the tyre size, and we will tell you what we measured

on something close. If we have not measured that class of machine yet, we will

tell you that too.

```

That last sentence matters. We would rather say "not yet" than guess.

FAQ

Why did one wheel position lose 37% of its packets?

Because of where the signal had to travel, not because of the sensor: the receiver was at the front-left of the cab, the rear-left wheel is the furthest point on the machine, and there was no repeater. The same sensor on the outer positions lost 1.0-1.8%.

Is 37% packet loss normal for 433 MHz TPMS?

No - 1-3% is normal on a machine in service. 37% means the layout was wrong for that wheel: no repeater, receiver at the wrong end of the chassis, and steel between the wheel and the receiver.

What fixes it?

A repeater at the rear of the machine. Not a different sensor, and not a different TPMS brand - every 433 MHz system loses packets behind a steel spreader, which is why the layout has to be planned from the axle drawing.

Can we get your test log?

Yes. Ask for the packet-loss log by wheel position and we send the log plus the analysis script. If we have not measured your class of machine, we say so instead of estimating - contact us or email [email protected].

← Tous les articles